Appeals Court Protects Transgender Service Members From Expulsion

Appeals Court Protects Transgender Service Members From Expulsion
Aerial view of the Pentagon in Arlington, Virginia.

Article Contents

Categories

A divided federal appeals court blocks Pentagon efforts to expel more than two dozen transgender troops while litigation continues. The 2-1 decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit rejected the administration’s request to pause a June ruling that protects current service members named in the lawsuit.

The ruling implements the panel’s earlier decision, which found that the administration unlawfully imposed its military ban. Plaintiffs’ attorneys say Tuesday’s order covers 27 service members. It does not permit new transgender recruits to join, according to the June majority opinion.

Court Blocks Pentagon Request to Pause Ruling

The administration had asked the appeals court to delay the June 1 ruling while it petitions the Supreme Court to hear the case. The Supreme Court previously allowed the ban to take effect during litigation in a separate case. Tuesday’s order could bring the dispute back before the nation’s highest court.

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth speaking
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth speaking.

In June, Circuit Judge Robert Wilkins, partially joined by Judge Judith Rogers, concluded that the Pentagon policy was designed to exclude people based on gender identity. Their majority barred the military from removing current service members covered by the lawsuit, but did not open enlistment to new transgender recruits.

Wilkins wrote Tuesday that the administration had not shown how retaining the plaintiffs currently serving would cause irreparable harm to the government or threaten national security. He also said the June ruling was narrower than an injunction the Supreme Court stayed last year. Wilkins added that he was unpersuaded by a general claim that any injunction against the executive branch causes irreparable harm.

The panel divided over whether to suspend the decision. Judge Justin Walker, who dissented from the June ruling, voted to grant the government’s request. Walker wrote then that judges lack the power to second-guess the decision to exclude transgender troops. Wilkins was nominated by President Barack Obama, Rogers by President Bill Clinton, and Walker by President Donald Trump, the source reported.

The Court Blocks Pentagon Policy During Appeal

The litigation follows a January 2025 executive order signed by Trump. The order asserted that transgender service members’ sexual identity conflicts with a soldier’s commitment to an honorable, truthful and disciplined lifestyle, including in personal life, and harms military readiness.

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth then issued a policy presumptively disqualifying people with gender dysphoria from military service. The source describes gender dysphoria as distress a person feels when assigned gender and gender identity do not match. A spokesperson for Hegseth’s office declined to comment on Tuesday’s ruling.

The case adds to disputes over how courts review government policy and apply legal standards. Law News Day has also covered the Supreme Court’s criticism of a high court and its examination of disputed criminal-law interpretations in appeals across the country. Another report describes the Supreme Court confronting questions of government accountability in court.

The appeals court’s order keeps the named plaintiffs in the military as the legal challenge proceeds. The administration’s petition asking the Supreme Court to take up the case remains the next stated route for seeking a different outcome. The Tuesday decision addresses the request to pause the circuit ruling, while the underlying challenge to the ban remains in litigation.

Read the Associated Press account of the divided appeals court decision.

Tags

Share
Spencer Hulse
Spencer Hulse is the Editorial Director at Grit Daily. He is responsible for overseeing other editors and writers, day-to-day operations, and covering breaking news.

Other articles

Appeals Court Protects Transgender Service Members From Expulsion
Aerial view of the Pentagon in Arlington, Virginia.

In This Article

Article Contents

Categories
Share
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
WhatsApp
Telegram
Share
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
WhatsApp
Telegram
Add Your Heading Text Here

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Add Your Heading Text Here

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.